Tendencies in the use of full participles in
the Russian written discourse: semantics and pragmatics of
non-standard patterns
DOI:10.30842/alp23065737191102137
Kuvshinskaya Yu. M., Zevakhina N. A.
Pleonasticheskiye prichastiya v sovremennoy russkoy rechi: funktsii
i tendentsii razvitiya. Acta Linguistica Petropolitana.
2023. 19(1): 138–192.
The paper studies tendencies in the use of full, single (i.e.,
occurring without their arguments) redundant participles in the
attributive position in Russian written discourse. Relying upon the
data of the Russian National Corpus and the Corpus of Russian
Student Texts, as well as on a number of examples collected from
various written sources, the prevalent types of the use of
redundant participles and their semantic, grammatical, pragmatic,
and communicative effects are described. The first of the four
identified types is the redundant, anaphoric use of participles
where they refer to certain fragments of the previous discourse.
Type two represents unnecessary use of appositive participles meant
to explicate some presupposed information even though it has been
already conveyed by the main clause. Type three emerges where
appositive participles break the basic information structure in
that they either convey some new information or actualize
information that has been already introduced in the previous
discourse. Type four is found where the speaker provides redundant
quantification information by inserting participles derived from
verbs like suščestvovat’, imet’sja ‘exist’, ‘be
available’, etc. Moreover, the use of redundant participles express
definiteness, aspectual or taxis meanings are described, as well.
The paper looks into the reasons that underlie the varying
linguistic phenomena. It demonstrates that these include the mutual
interference of the strategies of oral and written discourses, as
well as the influence of official, business, or neutral speech
patterns. Moreover, in many cases redundant participles are formed
from fixed word combinations (collocations). The speakers use such
ready-made combinations that are (semi-)automatically available to
them in their vocabulary. The authors argue that the use of such
pleonastic participles may be considered as a manifestation of some
ongoing grammaticalization processes.
Keywords
participle, non-standard uses, presupposition,
information structure, anaphora, determinacy, quantification,
collocations, official style, written discourse, oral
discourse
References
Apresjan 1995
Yu. D. Apresjan. Yazykovye anomalii:
tipy i funktsii [Language anomalies: types and functions]. R. I.
Kuzmenko (comp.). Res Philologia. Filologicheskie issledovaniya
(Philological studies). Moscow; Leningrad: Nauka, 1995.
Arutyunova, Shiryaev 1983
N. D. Arutyunova, E. N. Shiryaev.
Russkoe predlozhenie. Bytiynyy tip [Russian sentence. Copula type].
Moscow: Russkiy yazyk, 1983.
Bel’chikov 2012
Yu. A. Bel’chikov. Prakticheskaya
stilistika sovremennogo russkogo yazyka [Practical stylistics of
the contemporary Russian]. Moscow: AST-Press, 2012.
Bikkulova 2010
O. S. Bikkulova. Semantika i
tekstovyye funktsii deyeprichastiy v tekstakh vtoroy poloviny XVIII
— XIX vekov (k probleme formirovaniya sovremennoy normy) [Semantics
and textual functions of adverbs in texts of the second half of the
XVIII — XIX centuries (on the problem of the formation of a modern
norm)]. Diplomnaya rabota [Graduate thesis]. Moscow: Moscow State
University, 2010.
Bogdanova 1993
N. V. Bogdanova. O sintaksicheskikh
korrelyatakh differentsiatsii urovney rechevoy kultury. Zhivoe
slovo v russkoy rechi Prikamya [On syntactic correlates in
differentiation of the levels of speech culture. Current processes
in the Russian speech in Prikamye]. Perm: Perm State University
Press, 1993. P. 92–100.
Borisova 1995
E. P. Borisova. Slovo v tekste.
Slovar kollokatsii (ustoychivykh sochetaniy) russkogo yazyka s
anglo-russkim slovaryom klyuchevykh slov [Word in text. A
dictionary of Russian collocations (fixed word combinations) and an
English-Russian dictionary of key words]. Мoscow: Filologiya,
1995.
Borkovskii, Kuznetsov 1981
V. I. Borkovskii, P. S. Kuznetsov.
Istoricheskaya grammatika russkogo yazyka [A historical grammar of
Russian]. Мoscow: Vysshaya shkola, 1981.
Bulygina, Shmelev 1997
T. V. Bulygina, A. D. Shmelev.
Yazykovaya kontseptualizatsiya mira (na materiale russkoy
grammatiki) [Linguistic conceptualization of the world (Russian
grammar evidence)]. Мoscow: YARK, 1997.
Frey 2006
A. Frey. Grammatika oshibok [A
grammar of errors]. Moscow: Komkniga, 2006.
Gak 1979
V. G. Gak. Povtornaya nominatsiya na
urovne predlozheniya. Sintaksis teksta [Repeated nomination at the
sentence level. The syntax of text]. Moscow: Nauka, 1979. P.
91–102.
Golub 2007
I. B. Golub. Stilistika russkogo
yazyka [Stylistics of the Russian language]. Moscow: Ayris-Press,
2007.
Gorbachevich 1978
K. S. Gorbachevich. Variantnost slova
i yazykovaya norma (na materiale sovremennogo russkogo yazyka)
[Language variability and language norm (modern Russian evidence)].
Leningrad: Prosveshchenie, 1978.
Graudina, Shiryayev 2004
L. K. Graudina, E. N. Shiryayev
(eds.). Kultura russkoy rechi. Uchebnik dlya vuzov [The Russian
speech culture. A textbook for universities]. Мoscow: Norma,
2004.
Haiman, Thompson 1988
J. Haiman, S. Thompson (eds.). Clause
Combining in Grammar and Discourse. (Typological studies in
language, v. 18). Amsterdam; Philadelphia: John Benjamins
Publishing Company, 1988. P. 441–457.
Itskovich 1968
V. A. Itskovich. Yazykovaya norma
[Language norm]. Moscow: Prosveshcheniye, 1968.
Itskovich 1970
V. A. Itskovich. O yazykovoy norme
[On the language norm]. V. G. Kostomarov, L. I. Skvortsov.
Aktualnye voprosy kultury rechi [Current issues of the culture of
speech]. Moscow: Nauka, 1970. P. 54–62.
Kibrik 2003
A. A. Kibrik. Analiz diskursa v
kognitivnoy perspective [Discourse analysis in the cognitive
perspective]. Dr. habil. thesis. Moscow: Institute of Linguistics
of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 2003.
Kibrik, Podlesskaya 2006
A. A. Kibrik, V. I. Podlesskaya.
Problema segmentatsii ustnogo diskursa i kognitivnaya sistema
govoryashchego [A problem of oral discourse segmentation and the
speaker’s cognitive system]. V. D. Solov’yov (ed.). Kognitivnye
issledovaniya [Cognitive studies]. Vol. 1. Moscow: Institute of
Psychology RAS, 2006. P. 138–158.
Kobozeva 2012
I. M. Kobozeva. Lingvisticheskaya
semantika [Linguistic semantics]. Moscow: Knizhnyy dom “Librokom”,
2012.
Kopotev, Steksova 2016
M. V. Kopotev, T. I. Steksova.
Isklyuchenie kak pravilo: perekhodnye yavleniya v grammatike i
slovare [Exception as a rule: transitional phenomena in grammar and
vocabulary]. Moscow: Yazyki slavyanskoy kultury, 2016.
Kozintseva 2003
N. A. Kozintseva. Taksisnyye
funktsii, peredavayemyye prichastiyami i prichastnymi oborotami, v
russkom yazyke [Taxix functions conveyed by participles and
participial phrases in Russian]. A. V. Bondarko (ed.). Problemy
funktsionalnoy grammatiki. Semanticheskaya invariantnost /
variativnost [Problems of the functional grammar. Semantic
invariance / variability]. St. Petersburg: Nauka, 2003. P.
175–188.
Krylova 1992
O. A. Krylova. Kommunikativnyy
sintaksis russkogo yazyka [A communicative syntax of the Russian
language]. Moscow: Publishing House of RUDN University, 1992.
Kukushkina 1998
O. V. Kukushkina. Osnovnye tipy
rechevykh neudach v russkikh pismennykh tekstakh [Basic types of
speech failures in Russian written texts]. Moscow: Dialog-MGU,
1998.
Kustova 2005
G. I. Kustova. Kolichestvennye
znacheniya kachestvennykh slov [Quantitative meanings of
qualitative words]. N. D. Arutyunova (ed.). Logicheskiy analiz
yazyka [Logical analysis of language]. Мoscow: Indrik, 2005. P.
295–305.
Lapteva 2007
O. A. Lapteva. Zhivaya russkaya rech
s teleyekrana: Razgovornyy plast televizionnoy rechi v normativnom
aspekte [Russian vernacular on TV: The colloquial stratum of the TV
language from a normative aspect]. Moscow: URSS, 2003.
Letuchiy 2011
A. B. Letuchiy. Finitnost
[Finiteness]. Russkaya korpusnaya grammatika [Russian corpus
grammar]. Available at:
http://rusgram.ru/%D0%A4%D0%B8%D0%BD%D0%B8%D1%82%D0%BD%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%82%D1%8C
(accessed on 29.04.2022).
Paducheva 2007
E. V. Paducheva. Vyskazyvaniye i yego
sootnesennost s deystvitelnostyu [The utterance and its correlation
with reality]. Moscow: LKI, 2007.
Paducheva 2016
E. V. Paducheva. Mestoimeniya
svobodnogo vybora (lyuboy i seriya na -ugodno) [Pronouns of free
choice (lyuboy and the pronoun series in -ugodno)]. Russkaya
korpusnaya grammatika [Russian corpus grammar]. Available at:
http://rusgram.ru/%D0%9C%D0%B5%D1%81%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%B8%D0%BC%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B8%D1%8F_%D1%81%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BE_%D0%B2%D1%8B%D0%B1%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B0
(accessed on 29.04.2022).
Petrishcheva 1967
E. F. Petrishcheva. K voprosam o
kriteriyakh normativnosti [Towards the criteria of normativity].
Voprosy kultury rechi. 1967. No. 8. P. 241–147.
Rakhilina 2010
E. V. Rakhilina. Kognitivnyy analiz
predmetnykh imen: semantika i sochetayemost [A cognitive analysis
of substantive nouns: meaning and compatibility]. Moscow:
Azbukovnik, 2010.
Rakhilina 2014
E. V. Rakhilina. Grammatika oshibok:
v poiskakh konstant [A grammar of errors: in a search of
constants]. M. A. Daniel, A. E. Lyutikova, V. A. Plungian (eds.).
Yazyk. Konstanty. Peremennye. Pamyati A. E. Kibrika [Language.
Constants. Variables. In memoriam of A. E. Kibrik]. St. Petersburg:
Aleteya, 2014. P. 87–95.
Petrukhina, Sokolova 2008
E. V. Petrukhina, S. V. Sokolova.
Problemy grammatikalizatsii v sovremennom russkom yazyke [Problems
of grammaticalization in modern Russian]. A. V. Bondarko, S. A.
Shubik (eds.). Problemy funktsionalnoy grammatiki: Kategorizatsiya
semantiki [Problems of the functional grammar. Categorization of
meaning]. St. Petersburg: Nauka, 2008. P. 115–139.
Rozental’ 2010
D. E. Rozental’. Spravochnik po
pravopisaniyu i literaturnoy pravke [Spelling and literary text
revision: a manual]. Мoscow: Ayris-Press, 2010.
Rozhkova 2009
A. Yu. Rozhkova. Prichastiya i
deeprichastiya kak markery vysokogo urovnya kompetentsii
govoryashchego (na materiale zvukovogo korpusa russkoy rechi
yuristov) [Participles and converbs as markers of the speaker’s
high-level competence (on evidence of the corpus of recorded
Russian lawyers’ speech)]. Unpublished manuscript. St. Petersburg:
St. Petersburg State University Press, 2009.
Rusakova 2013
M. N. Rusakova. Elementy
antropotsentricheskoy grammatiki russkogo yazyka [Components of an
anthropocentric grammar of Russian]. Moscow: Yazyki slavyanskoy
kultury, 2013.
Say 2011
S. S. Say. Prichastie [Participle].
Russkaya korpusnaya grammatika [Russian corpus grammar]. Available
at:
http://rusgram.ru/%D0%9F%D1%80%D0%B8%D1%87%D0%B0%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B8%D0%B5
(accessed on 29.04.2022).
Sirotinina 1983
O. B. Sirotinina. Russkaya
razgovornaya rech [Russian colloquial speech]. Moscow:
Prosveshchenie, 1983.
Slovar 1999
A. P. Evgen’yeva (ed.). Slovar
russkogo yazyka [A dictionary of Russian]. In 4 vol. Moscow:
Poligrafresursy, 1999.
Solganik, Dronyayeva 2008
G. Ya. Solganik, T. S. Dronyayeva.
Stilistika sovremennogo russkogo yazyka i kultura rechi: uchebnoe
posobiye dlya stud. filol. fak. i fak. zhurnalistiki vysshikh
uchebnykh zavedeniy [Stylistics of the modern Russian language and
speech culture: a textbook for students of philological and
journalism faculties of higher educational institutions]. Moscow:
Akademiya, 2008.
Shvartskopf 1990
B. S. Shvartskopf. Kantselyarizmy
[Bureaucratese]. V. N. Yartseva (ed.). Lingvisticheskiy
yentsiklopedicheskiy slovar [A linguistic encyclopedic dictionary].
Moscow: Sovetskaya yentsiklopediya, 1990.
Tseytlin 1982
S. N. Tseytlin. Rechevye oshibki i
ikh preduprezhdenie: Posobie dlya uchiteley [Speech errors and
their prevention: A textbook for teachers]. Moscow: Prosveshchenie,
1982.
Tszyakhua 2007
Chzhan Tszyakhua. Aspektualnyye
semanticheskiye komponenty v znachenii imen sushchestvitelnykh v
russkom yazyke [Aspectual semantic components in the meaning of
nouns in the Russian language]. Voprosy Jazykoznanija. 2007. № 1.
P. 27–43.
Van Dijk 1980
T. A. Van Dijk. Yazyk, poznaniye,
kommunikatsiya [Language, cognition, communication]. Moscow:
Progress, 1989.
Van Dijk 1982
T. A. Van Dijk. Episodes as units of
dicourse analysis. D. Tannen (ed.). Analysing discourse: Text and
Talk. Washington, D. C.: Georgetown University Press, 1982.
Vasilevskaya 1997
L. I. Vasilevskaya. Pleonazm
[Pleonasm]. Yu. N. Karaulov (ed.). Russkiy yazyk. Yentsiklopediya
[Russian language. Encyclopedia]. Moscow: Drofa, 1997. P. 344.
192.
Vinogradov 1990
V. A. Vinogradov. Pleonazm
[Pleonasm]. V. N. Yartseva (ed.). Lingvisticheskiy
yentsiklopedicheskiy slovar [A linguistic encyclopedic dictionary].
Moscow: Sovetskaya yentsiklopediya, 1990.
Zemskaya et al. 1981
E. A. Zemskaya, M. V.
Kitaygorodskaya, E. N. Shiryaev. Russkaya razgovornaya rech
[Russian colloquial speech]. Moscow: Nauka, 1981.
Keywords
participle, non-standard uses, presupposition,
information structure, anaphora, determinacy, quantification,
collocations, official style, written discourse, oral
discourse