ISSN: 2306-5737E-ISSN: 2658-4069
Acta Linguistica Petropolitana
Transactions of the Institute for Linguistic Studies
ISSN: 2306-5737E-ISSN: 2658-4069
Acta Linguistica Petropolitana
Transactions of the Institute for Linguistic Studies 

On new reconstructions of PIE “laryngeals”, especially as uvular stops

DOI:10.30842/alp23065737181199215
PDF, 848.95 kb
Kümmel Martin Joachim. On new reconstructions of PIE “laryngeals”, especially as uvular stops. Acta Linguistica Petropolitana. 2022. 18(1): 199–215.

More than hundred years after the partial confirmation of the laryngeal theory by the Hittite evidence this aspect of the phonological reconstruction of Proto-Indo-European has remained one of the most controversial ones. While there is widespread agreement about the reconstruction of three “laryngeals”, their phonological interpretation is less clear. Recently, two radically different new interpretations have been proposed: 1) a reconstruction of just one “glottal fricative” (corresponding to *h₂) by Pyysalo [2013] with sharp critique of most assumptions of the received theory, and 2) a reinterpretation of *h₂ and *h₃ as uvular stops by Kloekhorst [2018], mainly based on their continuation as velar stops in Lycian and Carian. While the former proposal suffers from severe methodological weaknesses and is therefore not further discussed here, the latter seems more promising, as it is based on the usual methodology of comparative reconstruction applied to the actual evidence of Anatolian. After reviewing the most crucial general evidence for the reconstruction of “laryngeals”, especially cases of preserved consonants (including hitherto rarely considered evidence from Iranic), the arguments for uvular stops are discussed. Some problematic phonetic details of Kloekhorst's proposal are criticized, with the result that a reinterpretation according to this critique may even strengthen the general idea of uvular stops. Especially the assumption of *h₃ being a labialized fortis is rejected, instead it is argued that the evidence points to a non-labialized lenis obstruent, thus introducing a distinction typical for stops within the IE system. At the end, remaining problems are discussed, and an alternative scenario for the Anatolian development is mentioned (though not extensively discussed). The conclusion is that uvular stops might indeed be the original value of PIE *h₂ and *h₃ but they might have become uvular fricatives already in PIE, or in late Proto-Anatolian, and the stop reflexes of younger Anatolian languages could also be secondary, independent of the original status of the PIE sounds.

Keywords
Анатолийские языки, иранские языки, праиндоевропейский, фонологическая реконструкция, фонологическая типология, ларингальные, фрикативные, увулярные, смычные
References
Adiego 2007
I.-J. Adiego. The Carian language. Leiden: Brill, 2007.
Beekes 1989
R. S. P. Beekes. The nature of the Proto-Indo-European laryngeals. Th. Vennemann (ed.). The new sound of Indo-European. Essays in phonological reconstruction. Proceedings of a workshop held during the Seventieth International Conference on Historical Lin-guistics held Sept. 9–13, 1985 at the University of Pavia. Berlin; New York: Mouton de Gruyter, 1989. P. 23–33.
Beekes 1994
R. S. P. Beekes. Who were the laryngeals. J. E. Rasmussen (ed.). In honorem Holger Pedersen. Kolloquium der indogermanischen Gesellschaft vom 25. bis 28. März 1993. Wiesbaden: Reichert, 1994. P. 449–454.
Bozzone 2013
Ch. Bozzone. Ini-tial “Yod” in Greek and the Etymology of Gk. ἵππος 'horse'. S. W. Jamison, H. C. Melchert, B. Vine (eds.). Proceedings of the 24th Annual UCLA Indo-European Conference. Bremen: Hempen, 2013. P. 1–26.
Cohen, Hyllested 2012
P. Cohen, A. Hyllested. A new sound law of PIE: Initial **h₃w > *h₂w. B. N. Whitehead, Th. Olander, B. A. Olsen, J. E. Rasmussen (eds.). The Sound of Indo-European. Pho-netics, Phonemics and Morphophonemics. Selected papers from the conference held in Copenhagen, 16–19 April 2009. Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum, 2012. P. 53–72.
Eichner 1988
H. Eichner. Ana-tolisch und Trilaryngalismus. A. Bammesberger (Hrsg.). Die Laryngaltheorie und die Rekonstruktion des indogermanischen Laut- und Formensystems. Heidelberg: Winter, 1988. P. 123–151.
Gippert 1994
J. Gippert. Zur Phonetik der Laryngale. J. E. Rasmussen (ed.). In honorem Holger Pedersen. Kol-loquium der indogermanischen Gesellschaft vom 25. bis 28. März 1993. Wiesba-den: Reichert, 1994. P. 455–466.
Hendriksen 1941
H. Hendriksen. Untersuchungen über die Bedeutung des Hethitischen für die Laryngaltheorie. Copenhagen: Munksgaard, 1941.
Holopainen 2019
S. Holopainen. Indo-Iranian borrowings in Uralic: Critical overview of sound substitutions and distribution criterion. PhD Dissertation. Dissertation. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2019. Available at: http://urn.fi/URN:ISBN:978-951-51-5729-4 (ac-cessed on: 18.05.2022).
Janda 2000
M. Janda. Eleusis, das indogermanische Erbe der Mysterien. Innsbruck: Institut für Sprachwissen-schaft der Universität Innsbruck, 2000.
Katz 2003
H. Katz. Studien zu den älteren indoiranischen Lehnwörtern in den uralischen Sprachen. Heidel-berg: Winter, 2003.
Kimball 1987
S. E. Kimball. *H₃ in Anatolian. In: G. Cardona, N. H. Zide (eds.). Festschrift for Henry Hoenigswald. On the occasion of his Seventieth Birthday. Tübingen: Narr, 1987. P. 185–192.
Kloekhorst 2006
A. Kloekhorst. Initial Laryngeals in Anatolian. Historische Sprachforschung. 2006. Vol. 119. P. 77–108.
Kloekhorst 2012
A. Kloekhorst. The language of Troy. J. Kelder, G. Uslu, Ö. F. Şerifoğlu (eds.). Troy. City, Homer, Turkey. Amsterdam: W Books, 2012. P. 46–50.
Kloekhorst 2016
A. Kloekhorst. The Anatolian stop system and the Indo-Hittite hypothesis. Indogermanische Forschungen. 2016. Vol. 121. P. 213–247.
Kloekhorst 2018
A. Kloekhorst. Anatolian evidence suggests that the Indo-European laryngeals *h₂ and *h₃ were uvular stops. Indo-European Linguistics. 2018. Vol. 6. P. 69–94.
Koivulehto 1991
J. Koivulehto. Uralische Evidenz für die Laryngaltheorie. Wien: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1991.
Koivulehto 2001a
J. Koivulehto. Zum frühen iranischen und indoiranischen lexikalischen Einfluss auf das Fin-nisch-Ugrische. K. Karttunen, P. Koskikallio (eds.). Vidyā rṇ avavandanam: es-says in honour of Asko Parpola. Helsinki: Finnish Oriental Society, 2001. P. 359–378.
Koivulehto 2001b
J. Koivulehto. The earliest contacts between Indo-European and Uralic speakers in the light of lexical loans. Ch. Carpelan, A. Parpola, P. Koskikallio (eds.). Early Contacts between Uralic and Indo-European, Linguistic and Archaeological Considerations. Papers presented at an international symposium held at the Tvärminne Research Station of the University of Helsinki, 8–10 January 1999. Helsinki: Suoma-lais-Ugrilainen Seura, 2001. P. 235–263.
Kortlandt 2014
F. H. H. Kortlandt. The Tocharian verbal endings. Tocharian and Indo-European Studies. 2014. Vol. 15. P. 79–86.
Kümmel 2007
M. J. Kümmel. Konsonantenwandel. Bausteine zu einer Typologie des Lautwandels und ihre Konsequenzen für die vergleichende Rekonstruktion. Wiesbaden: Reichert, 2007.
Kümmel 2012
M. J. Kümmel. Typology and reconstruction: The consonants and vowels of Pro-to-Indo-European. B. N. Whitehead, Th. Olander, B. A. Olsen, J. E. Rasmussen (eds.). The Sound of Indo-European. Phonetics, Phonemics and Morphophone-mics. Selected papers from the conference held in Copenhagen, 16–19 April 2009. Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum, 2012. P. 291–329.
Kümmel 2016
M. J. Kümmel. Is ancient old and modern new? Fallacies of attestation and reconstruction (with special focus on Indo-Iranian). D. M. Goldstein, S. W. Jamison, B. Vine (eds.). Proceedings of the 27th Annual UCLA Indo-European Conference, Los Angeles, October 23rd and 24th, 2015. Bremen: Hempen, 2016. P. 79–96.
Kümmel 2018
M. J. Kümmel. The survival of laryngeals in Iranian. L. van Beek, A. Kloekhorst, G. Kroonen, M. Peyrot, T. Pronk (eds.). Farnah. Indo-Iranian and Indo-European studies in honor of Sasha Lubotsky. Ann Arbor: Beech Stave, 2018. P. 162–172.
Kümmel 2019
M. J. Kümmel. Thoughts about Pre-Indo-European stop systems. A. Kloekhorst, T. Pronk (eds.). The precursors of Proto-Indo-European: The Indo-Anatolian and Indo-Uralic hy-potheses. Leiden; Boston: Brill; Rodopi, 2019. P. 115–130.
Kümmel 2020
M. J. Kümmel. Substrata of Indo-Iranic and related questions. R. Garnier (ed.). Loanwords and substrata : proceedings of the colloquium held in Limoges (5th–7th June, 2018). Innsbruck: Institut für Sprachwissenschaft der Universität Innsbruck, 2020. P. 237–277.
Kümmel forthc.
M. J. Kümmel. Renaissance des Monolaryngalismus? Über Rekonstruktionsmethoden. B. Brog-yanyi, R. Lipp (eds.). Historische Linguistik II. Beiträge der Sektion „Historische Linguistik“ der 26. Jahrestagung der Gesellschaft für Sprache und Sprachen (Ge-SuS) e. V. „Traditionen und Erneuerungen“, 5.–8. April 2018, Université Paul Valéry, Montpellier. Hamburg: Dr. Kovač.
Kazansky 2012
N. N. Kazansky. The evidence for Lycian in the Linear A syllabary. Donum natalicium digitaliter confectum Gregorio Nagy septuagenario a discipulis collegis familiaribus oblatum (A virtual birthday gift presented to Gregory Nagy on turning seventy by his stu-dents, colleagues, and friends), 2012. Available at: https://www.academia.edu/41092710/The_Evidence_for_Lycian_in_the_Linear_A_Syllabary (accessed on 18.05.2022).
Kuryłowicz 1927
J. Kuryłowicz. Ə indo-européen et hittite. Symbolae Grammaticae in Honorem Ioannis Rozwadowski I. Krakau: Drukarnia Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, 1927. P. 95–104.
Mallory, Adams 1997
J. P. Mallory, D. Q. Adams (eds.). Encyclopedia of Indo-European culture. London; Chicago: Fitz-roy Dearburn, 1997.
Mallory, Adams 2006
J. P. Mallory, D. Q. Adams. The Oxford introduction to Proto-Indo-European and the Pro-to-Indo-European world. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006, 2006.
Melchert 1987
H. C. Melchert. Reflexes of *h₃ in Anatolian. Die Sprache. 1987. Vol. 33. P. 19–28.
Melchert 1994
H. C. Melchert. Anatolian historical phonology. Amsterdam; Atlanta: Rodopi, 1994.
Melchert 2004
H. C. Melchert. Second thoughts on PIE *y and *h₂ in Lydian. M. Mazoyer, O. Casabonne (eds.). Studia Anatolica et Varia. Mélanges offerts à Professeur René Lebrun. Vol. 2. Pa-ris: L'Harmattan, 2004. P. 139–150.
Melchert 2011
H. C. Melchert. The Proto-Indo-European verb for 'to pour' and medial *h₃ in Anatolian. S. W. Jamison, H. C. Melchert, B. Vine (eds.). Proceedings of the 22nd Annual UCLA Indo-European Conference. Bremen: Hempen, 2011. P. 127–132.
Møller 1906
H. Møller. Semi-tisch und Indogermanisch I (Konsonanten). Copenhagen: Hagerup, 1906.
Møller 1911
H. Møller. Ver-gleichendes indogermanisch-semitisches Wörterbuch. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1911.
Møller 1917
H. Møller. Die semitisch-vorindogermanischen laryngalen Konsonanten. Copenhagen: Høst, 1917.
Normier 1977
R. Normier. Idg. Konsonantismus, germ. „Lautverschiebung“ und Vernersches Gesetz. Zeitschrift für vergleichende Sprachforschung. 1977. Vol. 91. P. 171–218.
Olander 2019
Th. Olander. In-do-European cladistic nomenclature. Indogermanische Forschungen. 2019. Vol. 124. P. 231–244.
Pokorny 1959
J. Pokorny. Indo-germanisches etymologisches Wörterbuch. Vol. 1. Bern; München: Francke, 1959.
Pyysalo 2013
J. Pyysalo. System PIE. The primary phoneme inventory and sound law system for Pro-to-Indo-European. Helsinki: UnigrafiaOy, 2013. Available at: http://ethesis.helsinki.fi (accessed on 18.05.2022).
Pyysalo, Janhunen 2018a
J. Pyysalo, J. Janhunen. Indo-European Linguistics in the 21st century (1): From trilaryngeal-ism to monolaryngealism: returning to Oswald Szemerényi. Proto-Indo-European Linguistics — Urindogermanische Sprachforschungen. 2018. Vol. 1. P. 1–5.
Pyysalo, Janhunen 2018b
J. Pyysalo, J. Janhunen. Indo-European Linguistics in the 21st century (2): On Frederik Kort-landt's distributional trilaryngealistic model. Proto-Indo-European Linguistics — Urindogermanische Sprachforschungen. 2018. Vol. 2. P. 1–14.
Pyysalo, Janhunen 2019
J. Pyysalo, J. Janhunen. Indo-European Linguistics in the 21st century (3): Optimizing the lar-yngeal theory: Testing the models of Puhvel, Eichner and Melchert/Rix against Szemerényi's monolaryngealism. Proto-Indo-European Linguistics — Urindo-germanische Sprachforschungen. 2019. Vol. 1. P. 1–16.
Rasmussen 1983
J. E. Rasmussen. Determining proto-phonetics by circumstantial evidence: the case of the In-do-European laryngeals. F. Karlsson (ed.). Papers from the Seventh Scandinavian Conference of Linguistics. Vol. 2. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, Department of General Linguistics, 1983. P. 371–384.
Rasmussen 1992
J. E. Rasmussen. Initial h₃ in Anatolian: A vote for chaos. Copenhagen Working Papers in Linguis-tics. 1992. Vol. 2. P. 53–61.
Rasmussen 1994
J. E. Rasmussen. On the phonetics of the IE laryngeals. J. E. Rasmussen (ed.). In honorem Holger Pedersen. Kolloquium der indogermanischen Gesellschaft vom 25. bis 28. März 1993. Wiesbaden: Reichert, 1994. P. 433–447.
Rasmussen 1999
J. E. Rasmussen. Selected papers on Indo-European Linguistics. With a Section on Comparative Eskimo Linguistics. 2 vols. Kopenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press, 1999.
Ringe 1996
D. Ringe. On the chronology of sound changes in Tocharian. Vol. 1. From Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Tocharian. New Haven: American Oriental Society, 1996.
Rix 1985
H. Rix. Schrift und Sprache. M. Cristofani (ed.). Die Etrusker. Stuttgart; Zürich: Belser, 1985.
Rix 2004
H. Rix. Etruscan. R. D. Woodard (ed.). The Cambridge Encyclopedia of the World's Ancient Lan-guages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004. P. 943–966.
Saussure 1879
F. de Saussure. Mémoire sur le système primitif des voyelles dans les langues indo-européennes. Leipzig: Teubner, 1879.
Saussure 1922
F. de Saussure. Recueil des publications scientifiques de Ferdinand de Saussure. Lausanne; Genève: Payot, 1922.
Steinbauer 1999
D. Steinbauer. Neues Handbuch des Etruskischen. St. Katharinen: Scripta Mercaturae, 1999.
Tichy 2004
E. Tichy. Indo-germanistisches Grundwissen für Studierende sprachwissenschaftlicher Diszip-linen. 2., überarb. Aufl. Bremen: Hempen, 2004.
Wallace 2008
R. E. Wallace. Zikh Rasna: A manual of the Etruscan language and inscriptions. Ann Arbor: Be-ech Stave Press, 2008.
Weiss 1995
M. Weiss. Life everlasting, Latin iūgis “everflowing“, Greek ὑγιής “healthy“, Gothic ajukdūþs “eternity”, and Avestan yauuaēǰī- “living forever”. Münchener Studien zur Sprachwissenschaft. 1995. Vol. 55. P. 131–156.
Weiss 2016
M. Weiss. The Proto-Indo-European laryngeals and the name of Cilicia in the Iron Age. A. M. Byrd, J. DeLisi, M. Wenthe (eds.). Tavet tat satyam. Studies in honor of Jared S. Klein on the occasion of his seventieth birthday. Ann Arbor: Beech Stave Press, 2016. P. 331–339.
Yates 2019
A. Yates. The phonology, phonetics, and diachrony of Sturtevant's Law. Indo-European Lin-guistics. 2019. Vol. 7. P. 241–307.
Keywords
Анатолийские языки, иранские языки, праиндоевропейский, фонологическая реконструкция, фонологическая типология, ларингальные, фрикативные, увулярные, смычные
ScopusSCImago Journal & Country RankE-Library.ruCrossRefCyberLeninkaVAKERIH Plus